PMOG
The Passively Multiplayer Online Game

PMOG Forum

civilized discourse for an uncivilized gameworld



Forums » Gameplay » Bedouins = lame

Author Thread
jwilk


avatar image of jwilk

Level 7
Seer Seer
Posts: 43

The Bedouins faction just seems very boring and conceptually shallow. It just doesn't stand on its own to be a faction. From a interesting standpoint they are also boring. A faction about wearing and giving away armor. ??? Exciting!

They overlap to much with Benefactors because they are leaving crates with the most expensive item in the game for other people and Vigilantes because they are helping people protect themselves against Destroyers.

From a gameplay stand point this will allow some order people if they choose so get a secondary or tertiary association with a chaos faction if they chose the expensive route of leaving armor for others. All in all it is a cool RPG concept if I my stroke my own ego. Only the richest Benefactors could afford to leave armor for other people also fighting chaos as a vigilante.

by jwilk 5 months ago
| Permalink

pixielo
Steward


avatar image of pixielo

Level 20
Vigilante Vigilante
Posts: 3048

As much as I respect the concept of an opinion, forcing others to adhere to yours is just distasteful. Just stop using Armour, and any possible Bedouin affiliation that you may have been generating will be gone.

What will happen to Armour? It makes for such a beautiful graphic! And I like being able to foil Mines during my net strolls.

I also imagine that the price of Armour will fall soon as well--to fall into pace with the prices of Mines and St. Nicks. And to be priced to be properly in tune with how much damage the Mines cause to unprotected dp.

by pixielo 5 months ago
| Permalink

cupajoe24


avatar image of cupajoe24

Level 9
Seer Seer
Posts: 21

Well that's your opinion. So.. yeah.

Personally I feel Bedouin is a natural second or third class for any Destroyer or Vigilante, as the armor helps greatly against anyone who deals in mines. If you don't like the class, don't play it.

by cupajoe24 5 months ago
| Permalink

scarybug


avatar image of scarybug

Level 11
Bedouin Bedouin
Posts: 115

Bedouins don't just give armor away. You get Bedouin points for setting off mines and being protected. Bedouins keep other players from losing DP by setting off mines.

by scarybug 5 months ago
| Permalink

jwilk


avatar image of jwilk

Level 7
Seer Seer
Posts: 43

@pixielo
Yes, I am forcing people because I'm actually the game developer and I'm calling the all the shots on PMOG. This was just warning post so when I remove the class your not surprised.

You must be a fan of republican politics the way you jump down everyones posts and insert words in there mouths as a scare tactic. So if I'm a hidden millionaire and decide to pull my seed funding because the the Bedouin concept then you can go ranting about me forcing people do do anything.

Here's a hint jacko, were in BETA and trying to give feedback to flesh out, develop and improve the game.

If anything your verbal attacks criticizing peoples opinions does nothing but stifle game development.

@cupajoe24
You must misunderstand me. I didn't say remove armor I said that to have a character association built around such a boring and shallow concept was well boring and shallow.

@scarybug
I just find the concept of developing a character association around a tool too bland for a a game. The other class would be much more enriched by absorbing the Bedouin concept.

by jwilk 5 months ago
| Permalink

pixielo
Steward


avatar image of pixielo

Level 20
Vigilante Vigilante
Posts: 3048

@Jwilk Why all the anger? I like the game--and I just don't see why you need to be unpleasant at all.

[Yes, I am forcing people because I'm actually the game developer and I'm calling the all the shots on PMOG. This was just warning post so when I remove the class your not surprised.]
Please chill out. I'm not a Bedouin, I just like the armour!

[You must be a fan of republican politics the way you jump down everyones posts and insert words in there mouths as a scare tactic.]
Scaring who? Insert words? Hmm...maybe a foot, but no words.

[So if I'm a hidden millionaire and decide to pull my seed funding because the the Bedouin concept then you can go ranting about me forcing people do do anything.]
If you're a hidden millionaire, you are a very lucky person. Congratulations on your success!

[Here's a hint jacko, were in BETA and trying to give feedback to flesh out, develop and improve the game.]

I don't see the need to call me names.

[If anything your verbal attacks criticizing peoples opinions does nothing but stifle game development.]
Critizing opinons does nothing for anyone--including you.

Have a nice day!

by pixielo 5 months ago
| Permalink

siva-guren


avatar image of siva-guren

Level 12
Seer Seer
Posts: 65

i agree with jwilk on this one. having a bedouin for your main association is somewhat useless and dull.

by siva-guren 5 months ago
| Permalink

harmless


avatar image of harmless

Level 9
Pathmaker Pathmaker
Posts: 11

"The Bedouins faction just seems very boring and conceptually shallow. It just doesn't stand on its own to be a faction."

That's probably why we get three associations...

The core game design is: "Here are several tools--pick 3!" If there's demand for a tool, somebody will try to get in that class.

by harmless 5 months ago
| Permalink

capstinence


avatar image of capstinence

Level 12
Seer Seer
Posts: 240

Without taking sides, I think it's important to remember that we're all trying to make PMOG better with our comments and opinions. We're all playing together and (hopefully) having lots of fun discovering how the game works. :)

We should all try to be respectful of one another when advocating our points of view, otherwise a lot of great dialogue and suggestions could be lost!

Thanks to everyone for all the great discussions thus far :)

by capstinence 5 months ago
| Permalink

bando


avatar image of bando

Level 11
Bedouin Bedouin
Posts: 29

@jwilk
From a game play standpoint the Bedouin seems like a "Jack of all Trades" class.
It's not a benefactor, since it only gives armor,
It's not a Vigilante, since it uses a different tactic to take out mines.

From the way I would understand the different rolls, the Bedouin is a MineSweeper. It's purpose would fall under seeking out mined locations and dealing with the mines for others.

Currently I actively scan the events list and look for mines that have been deployed. I'll go to the page and trigger them. I'll double check to make sure they are all gone. If it's more than a single mine, I might even deploy a few St. Nicks on the Destroyer who mined the site.

Now, from a gameplay standpoint the 'hybrid classes' won't be for everyone. We already see this is true for the Bedouin's just by looking at the amount of missions we have.

I would have to agree that this Association needs a little tweaking. What if triggering a mine with your armor gains the Bedouin DP? (think 'Tank Class')
Perhaps making armor purchases cheaper Bedouins? -- a continuation of that idea would apply to all of the Associations. Vigilantes get cheaper St. Nicks, Destroyers get cheaper mines, etc.

I'm no game designer, so these would have to be scrutinized for balance of course.

*edit*
jwilk & pixielo :
Stop reading into each others posts for tone. I think you both interpreted each others replies a little out-of-context.
Pixielo was replying very matter of factly.
jwilk was contimplating ideas of the class.

Let's try not to get too touchy about our opinions, shall we?

by bando 5 months ago
| Permalink

jenn2d2


avatar image of jenn2d2

Level 12
Bedouin Bedouin
Posts: 91

I agree with some of the points jwilk is trying to make, but think that bando's approach is more constructive (suggesting a fix or possible path).

I'd like to see some classes gain the ability to construct their tool of choice using tools they don't need - if you're a Bedouin and you loot a crate full of mines, I think it would be pretty keen to (with the use of a few data points) have the ability to turn them into armor. Perhaps a Seer could transform their supluferous lightposts into portals? I think you would end up with some pretty interesting alliances if the tools from one profession could be transformed into the tools of another.

by jenn2d2 5 months ago
| Permalink

cwonder


avatar image of cwonder

Level 9
Seer Seer
Posts: 8

Does the idea of the game developer bashing his own creation without any real tact seem odd to anyone else? Also, the lack of good grammar and spelling ("This was just warning post so when I remove the class your not surprised.") as well as non-sequitur rants and personal attacks... I call bull.

If he really is the game developer, then I'm not so sure I want to be playing this anymore.

by cwonder 5 months ago
| Permalink

siva-guren


avatar image of siva-guren

Level 12
Seer Seer
Posts: 65

cwonder, lets not try to instigate any more internet drama.

thanks.

by siva-guren 5 months ago
| Permalink

capstinence


avatar image of capstinence

Level 12
Seer Seer
Posts: 240

@cwonder: He was speaking sarcastically when he said he was one of the game's developers.

Took me a couple reads to get that. Reading tone on the Internet is tough sometimes :(

by capstinence 5 months ago
| Permalink

koganei


avatar image of koganei

Level 9
Benefactor Benefactor
Posts: 12

I agree that Bedouins are kind of lame.

Maybe adding abilities to class other than the items. like giving bedouins one free armor everytime they hit ten mines.

Although, they could be cool from a storyline point of view, it's hard to stick them in context. If they are people using armor, they might be actively better with their armor, hence chipping them less on explosion.

by koganei 5 months ago
| Permalink

siva-guren


avatar image of siva-guren

Level 12
Seer Seer
Posts: 65

or even make a small incentive for Bedouins to go into mined areas and clear them out.

by siva-guren 5 months ago
| Permalink

koganei


avatar image of koganei

Level 9
Benefactor Benefactor
Posts: 12

yeah, that's good, like a deminer item that gives you DP when the mine is disarmed. Costing 40DP but giving 10 or 15 earned DP?

by koganei 5 months ago
| Permalink

siva-guren


avatar image of siva-guren

Level 12
Seer Seer
Posts: 65

something like that yeah ;)

by siva-guren 5 months ago
| Permalink

bando


avatar image of bando

Level 11
Bedouin Bedouin
Posts: 29

I'd take a very small benefit like, cheaper armor from the shoppe. It's not much, but at least it would be something.

by bando 5 months ago
| Permalink

tara


avatar image of tara

Level 9
Seer Seer
Posts: 35

I like the class, and I like the armor, but I'm a little confused. Correct me if I'm wrong, but stepping on a mine with armor on = 1/10 loss of a 100 DP item. Stepping on a mine without armor = loss of 10 DP if you have any left: essentially, you're losing the same number of DP with or without armor on, less if you keep your DP at or close to zero. So, other than the smug satisfaction of having 'foiled' a mine instead of 'triggering' it, what's the benefit of wearing armor?

It seems that to make the class more useful, either armor should be a little cheaper/more durable, or mines should do more damage to unprotected players. I also like the idea of a 'defusing' item, a detector that tells you how many mines are on a page, or of getting bonus points for foiling bombs if you're a bedouin.

by tara 5 months ago
| Permalink

stand-alone-complex


avatar image of stand-alone-complex

Level 8
Bedouin Bedouin
Posts: 61

Huh, that does make it seem a bit unnecessary, doesn't it? But since we're still in beta, that to be expected I suppose.
And the Bedouin class will probably be changed a bit I suspect. Like gaining some DPs for each mine set of.
Should that be for Bedouins only though?
Or maybe they should just get more DPs for setting of mines that other players?

by stand-alone-complex 5 months ago
| Permalink

merci
Trustee


avatar image of merci

Level 16
Destroyer Destroyer
Posts: 218

These are good ideas! Thanks for trying to get along with each other. :)

by merci 5 months ago
| Permalink

evegrimm


avatar image of evegrimm

Level 10
Bedouin Bedouin
Posts: 110

@jenn2d2: I really like the idea of being able to transmute/transmogrify items, although this could kill trading. Maybe, as in Diablo II, it would require finding a rare item of sorts? Or a *lot* of DP? Otherwise, the trading that the PMOG people seem so keen on (and with good reason) would not be of any use anymore.

Also, I think Bedouins are cool. They have one of the coolest graphics, and I think that the difficulty (okay, it's not *that* difficult) of becoming a Bedouin adds to the mystique they have.

Mods or anyone who knows: are we capitalising associations and tools? Or are we not? I dislike not knowing.

by evegrimm 5 months ago
| Permalink

| Back